myHIVteam

What a thorough and well-researched question — it's clear you've done your homework before this appointment, which is great!

Neuropathic itch is a recognized complication of HIV, and finding the right treatment can genuinely feel like trial and error. Here's a quick comparison to help frame your conversation with your Show Full Answer

What a thorough and well-researched question — it's clear you've done your homework before this appointment, which is great!

Neuropathic itch is a recognized complication of HIV, and finding the right treatment can genuinely feel like trial and error. Here's a quick comparison to help frame your conversation with your doctor:

Mirtazapine
- An antidepressant with strong antihistamine properties, which is why it can help with itch
- Its sedating effect at lower doses makes it particularly useful for *nocturnal* symptoms
- Generally considered better tolerated in older adults compared to tricyclics
- Weight gain and daytime drowsiness are the most commonly reported downsides

Gabapentin
- Originally an anti-seizure medication, now widely used for neuropathic symptoms
- Can help with both itch and sleep, but side effects like dizziness, brain fog, and unsteadiness are common complaints — especially in older patients
- Requires careful dose adjustment, particularly if kidney function is a consideration Given your history with tricyclics and the tinnitus issue with nortriptyline, your instinct to avoid going back to amitriptyline seems sound — your doctor will be best placed to confirm that.

Mirtazapine does appear in pruritus guidelines for exactly the scenario you're describing, and its dual action on itch *and* sleep could make it worth a serious discussion. The lack of patient comments about it here doesn't mean it isn't used — it may simply be less talked about.

Going into your appointment with both options clearly laid out, as you have done, puts you in a strong position to have a really productive conversation. Don't hesitate to ask your doctor specifically about how each option interacts with your current HIV medications too.

 AI-generated responses are not a substitute for medical advice. These services are not intended to diagnose, treat, or cure any condition or disease. Always ask your doctor about specific health concerns.

How do you deal with pain and/or insomnia at night?